INC-2025-0011SEV3 · MediumData leakReported

Shared ChatGPT conversations show up in Google search results

An opt-in checkbox let shared ChatGPT conversations be indexed by search engines. After reports that thousands were searchable, OpenAI removed the feature.

Disclosed
Published
Updated
Organization
OpenAI
System
ChatGPT conversation sharing
Impact
Thousands of shared conversations indexed by search engines, according to press reports; feature removed

Timeline

  • Late July 2025. Fast Company reports that shared conversations appear in Google results.
  • 2025-07-31. OpenAI’s chief information security officer announces that the feature is being removed.

Trigger or entry point

Users ticking “Make this chat discoverable” when creating a public link.

Failure mechanism

The option was opt-in. A smaller line of text under the checkbox explained that the chat could be shown in web searches. No model failed here: the cause was a product design that made it easy to publish a conversation without meaning to. The checkbox appeared in the same pop-up that creates a public link to a conversation.

Impact

Engadget reports that Fast Company found thousands of indexed conversations. Neither source gives a figure from OpenAI. Engadget dates the Fast Company article to earlier the same week, and the announcement of the removal to Thursday.

Response

OpenAI’s security chief called the feature a “short-lived experiment” and said it created too many chances for people to share things by accident. OpenAI removed it. According to Malwarebytes, the change was rolling out to all users by the next morning. Both reports quote the statement, which was posted on X. The post is no longer available there.

Mitigations

OpenAI said it was working with search engines to remove indexed content. Malwarebytes notes that cached results may stay visible for a time.

Engineering takeaway

Failure pattern
A sharing dialog offered public search indexing through a checkbox whose effect many users did not understand.
Preventive control
Keep "share with a person" and "publish to the web" as separate actions with separate confirmation.
Transferable lesson
An opt-in protects users only if they understand what they are opting into.

Editorial summary by Incidents.si, drawn from the sourced record above. It is not a statement by the organizations involved.

Sources

  1. OpenAI is removing ChatGPT conversations from Googlesecondary · 2025-08-01
  2. OpenAI kills "short-lived experiment" where ChatGPT chats could be found on Googlesecondary · 2025-08-01

Corrections

  1. The statement by OpenAI’s security chief on X, cited as the primary source, is no longer available at its address. The entry now rests on two press reports that quote it, so the evidence level changed from Confirmed to Reported.2026-11-16
Report a correction